Tantabus
Filters (Default) SettingsRegisterLogin
Character LoRAs - Want more character variety? Then check This List!
đź‘» Ghost Signatures! Want to know how to easily remove them? - Check Here!
1 2 2 0 21
Subscribe
Galleries
Featured in
Sign in to create a gallery
Related
View VS Download DS
Uploaded by Importer
 3612x2182 PNG 5.67 MB
Description

Image imported from Derpibooru.
Original: https://derpibooru.org/images/2966699
Metadata at the time of import:
Field Data
Favorites 9
Upvotes 31
Downvotes 12
Score 19
Comments 21
Uploader Paracompact
Original description below this line
An AI art Turing test of sorts—you don’t know which, or how many, pieces of the art above were made (almost) entirely with AI. Of the half dozen or so people I’ve given these tests to, so far, none have gotten a perfect score.
All images were generated by me from a txt2img base, and most had some iterative img2img/inpainting/manual guidance steps. Very small blemishes in AI images were removed in a minute or two with a smudge brush or color correction tool.
Answers and attributions follow:
  1. ||Human, by koviry—https://derpibooru.org/images/2885781||
  2. ||Human, by koviry again—https://derpibooru.org/images/2885773||
  3. ||Human, by RocketLawnChair—https://derpibooru.org/images/2104500||
  4. ||Human, by multiverseequine-https://derpibooru.org/images/2910461||
  5. AI—Some leg weirdness going on, and shadow is wrong.
  6. AI—Doe’s antlers are asymmetric, buck’s back hoof is odd, speckles are uneven.
  7. AI—Cutie mark is wrong, eyes and horn leave something to be desired.
  8. ||Human, by crimmharmony—https://derpibooru.org/images/2205115||
  9. AI—Artifacting on her chest between her mane, odd beanie.
  10. AI—Far ear is different from near, far hindleg is odd (maybe).
How did you do?

Tags
Edit History (2)
safe
17664 ai assisted
1421 ai generated
50869 artist:koviry
1 artist:rocket-lawnchair
1 automatically imported
33021 derpibooru import
33215 edit
604 editor:paracompact
41 generator:purplesmart.ai
5036 generator:stable diffusion
23569 fluttershy
4575 princess luna
3119 stygian
9 twilight sparkle
5163 alicorn
8878 alpaca
10 deer
74 goat
4 pony
25035 g4
45356 cute
5334 female
49929 high res
3571 horn
20215 moon
1400 quiz
2 twilight sparkle (alicorn)
1506
Report Share List favoriters

Comments

Edit Preview
Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ ~sub~

Detailed syntax guide

21 comments posted
Background Pony #167F
Only mistake is the third one, but I was honestly unsure of myself for that one as I was looking from my phone and only zoomed a bit as I wanted to see all pictures at once. So 9/10 !
Imported from Derpibooru
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
@Background Pony #167F
I’ve removed your artist tag so it doesn’t show up under your works.
If any other artist would like their tag or this image removed, let me know.
@Background Pony #167F
Please consider asking artists for their permission before using their works in edits like this.
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by Ciaran
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
Dunno how I feel about my stuff being on a “Is this AI or not?” Not offended or anything, and I’m uninterested in doing anything about it. #4 if anyone was wondering.
Imported from Derpibooru
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
I trying making MLP art with stable diffusion,but the AI give me real horse art instead pony (even I add pony and MLP words)
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by Yuyu260
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
@Background Pony #167F
Another limitation i see with the AI stuff is expressions. They all seem to have the same generic smile, or the same horny face if it’s a lewd pic.
I’ve not seen it pull off something like the grumpy expression in number 8. There’s definitely room for more variety there, I think.
But it’s definitely getting difficult to tell the difference at a glance, and to be fair, i think art is usually consumed at a glance; most people aren’t going to pore over minor details to find AI artifacts.
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by PaskaNaakka
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
@Background Pony #167F
Nice. Yeah, it’s such a weird mix of local and global strengths and weaknesses with the AI, and I’ve yet to read a good explanation for why it is the way it is. I wonder what the AI images will look like a year from now?
Also, I’m salty about the microphone, because I fixed it in a final inpainting, but somehow I included the wrong version on the test :s
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by Paracompact
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
Got them all :V
But then again, I kinda know what to look for. There’s usually some telltale weirdness AI does that a human artist wouldn’t. Like the microphone in number 6.
What I find interesting is that the AI often struggles with things like anatomy, limb placement and stuff. It’s like you gave the colouring and rendering skills of a fairly skilled artist to someone makes rookie mistakes with anatomy. It’s a weird dissonance.
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by PaskaNaakka
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
60% accuracy here. For example, on #7 I assumed that the artist had left in some sketch lines on the eyes, and I completely missed that the cutie mark was inaccurate.
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by 𝗪𝖎𝖗𝖊𝖇𝖆𝖑𝖑
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
I started off strong but that’s because I can recognize Koviry’s art style on sight lol, I usually guessed human on the AI but always guessed human on the human ones. So I guess I’m too trusting of things being human when they’re maybe not haha
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by Krickis
Posted Report
Background Pony #167F
@Background Pony #167F
Yeah, at the moment it takes someone who knows at least a little bit what to look for. Every AI image has some sort of tell, though, and it seems that experienced artists have earned the best scores so far.
Imported from Derpibooru - Posted by Paracompact
Posted Report